Journalistic Faux Pas

I am not sure what source of information Mr. Fisk relied on to issue his rather ridiculous statement- “Law 174 is actually being obeyed in Lebanon”. Your source Mr. Fisk is either a prisoner in his own home, or is on a constant high (excuse my french). I was quite stunned when I visited Beirut for Christmas break 2 months back, as I observed what restaurants/pubs/clubs were making of the 174 law  (pertaining to smoking bans inde14fb4d6f5f611e1bfc622000a1cde39_6oors). Below are two scenarios I’ve personally witnessed:

– Le Mall Dbayyeh: While no one was smoking inside the shops, two ladies were actually smoking in the ladies-room, and then the cleaner in charge made a theatrical appearance, also a cigarette in hand, earning herself two bows of respect.

– Le Mandaloun: The evening of December 23rd was apparently declared a “public” holiday by Le Mandaloun Management. As we made our way to our table that evening, clouds of smoke were happily filling up the place, and as I curiously approached one of the overjoyed waiters and asked the forbidden question, he gave me an “Are you kidding me?!” look and quickly followed that up with: “Madame, please, we allow smoking during public holidays!” I had to apologize for my ignorance before heading back to my seat.

Whether we are abiding by the smoking ban Law or not is not the issue here. What I don’t appreciate about Mr.Fisk’s article is the fact that he:

– either wrote it with no reliable source of information whatsoever and without double checking his facts;

or (one can’t help but question his shrewdness)

– wrote it knowing this information was not credible, but published it regardless for personal or professional purposes.

As a modest Lebanese reader living abroad, transparency and credibility of the news I read about my country, whether good or bad, are of immense importance to me. Transparency and credibility make good journalists Mr. Fisk, and today you aren’t one.

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/robert-fisk-a-mistyeyed-farewell-to-lebanons-smoky-nargile-dens-8528083.html

Advertisements

About monakaraoui

Editor by day, journal blogger by night.. View all posts by monakaraoui

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: